Hi Problemchild,
Apologies for the delay in getting back to you. I was in England at Waxstock and then teaching some classes with Kelly Harris and then had a delay getting back to the USA. Good to be back home and back to work.
Here's your picture,
To be honest - I have not worked on one of these Jeep tops that have the dull, flat textured surface for some time and now don't remember what I used. My guess is a quality AIO would be a good product to test and and if it works - stick with it. If it were me, and I've used the brands you've mentioned, I would go with 3D SPEED. It uses great abrasive technology and works on pretty much darned near everything I've ever used it on.
I don't trust any products from CG that use abrasive technology - this means I would not use nor do I trust any compounds, polishes or aios (the product that use abrasive technology). In my life - I've answered a lot of questions from people on how to REMOVE micro-marring after using CG abrasive products and this is a sign to me they use crap for abrasive technology.
Griot's "BOSS" products use very good abrasive technology - I would have to test any other product they sell that uses abrasive technology before recommending it. I was not impressed with their Complete Compound or Complete Polish.
FWIW
I was still at Meguiar's when 3M bought them. In a meeting Gary Gunderson told everyone that 3M wasn't going to make any changes, I think he said,
If it ain't broke don't fix it
And a few years later, it was inevitable, they started fixing Meguiar's. Now the one thing that made the company unique is lost forever. I also wrote the concept paper for NXT Tech Wax. It was page 31 in this report I wrote for all the old upper management team at Meguair's back in 2003 called,
The Zaino Case Study
Someday I'll share the entire story.
One thing for sure - you can't go wrong with 3D products. I could have joined pretty much any company you can name when I left the geek and I purposefully chose 3D because I really like their products and just as important - the owner and the team he's assembled are genuinely nice people that treat you with respect - like family. Good products and good people.
You can trust any products with the 3D label are actually MADE by 3d - not some blender companies product with a marketing label slapped onto the bottle.
